The appointment of referee Anthony Taylor for this weekend’s pivotal Premier League clash between Manchester City and Arsenal has sparked debate, with broadcaster Richard Keys openly criticising the decision and directing his concerns toward PGMOL chief Howard Webb.
Sunday’s meeting, scheduled for April 19, has been framed as a potentially decisive moment in the title race.
Arsenal currently sit six points clear at the top of the table, although City have the advantage of a game in hand. With so much at stake, the fixture has widely been labelled the standout encounter of the season.
PGMOL opted to hand responsibility for officiating the contest to Taylor, one of the most experienced referees in English football.
He will be assisted by Gary Beswick and Ian Hussin, while Paul Tierney has been named as fourth official. John Brooks and Stuart Burt are set to oversee proceedings from the VAR hub.
Despite Taylor’s extensive experience at the highest level, the appointment has not gone without criticism.
Keys, writing in his personal blog, raised concerns centred not on the referee’s competence, but on the potential pressure linked to his geographical ties.
Keys questions suitability of Taylor appointment
Keys took issue with the decision to appoint Taylor, pointing to the official’s roots in Wythenshawe and current residence in Altrincham, both located close to Manchester.
“I do wish the PL had appointed a different ref for the game v City this weekend,” he wrote.
“They’ve named ‘Altrincham’s’ Anthony Taylor. Why do they stubbornly do this sort of thing? I’ll repeat what I always say – not for a minute do I think Taylor will make bad decisions on purpose, but what if…?”
His argument centred on the added scrutiny and pressure that could accompany such an appointment in a match of this magnitude.
“What if he makes a big call and it’s wrong? Why put him under that kind of pressure? It’s Taylor I feel for.
“If you’re telling me we don’t have another ref good enough to handle the game of the season, then that’s a further indictment on Howard Webb and the PGMOL.”
Keys’ remarks underline a broader debate that occasionally surfaces in English football regarding refereeing neutrality and the optics of appointments, particularly when officials are based near clubs involved in high-profile fixtures.
However, Taylor has previously made clear that he supports non-League side Altrincham and holds no allegiance to either Manchester City or Manchester United, nor to Arsenal.
Support for Taylor amid neutrality debate
While Keys has voiced his reservations, others within the game have defended both Taylor and the decision-making of PGMOL.
Former referee Graham Scott suggested that such concerns are not new, but emphasised that Taylor’s professional integrity should not be questioned.
“Eyebrows are sometimes raised when he is appointed to a match involving either of the Manchester giants, given he lives within a few miles of both grounds,” Scott told The Athletic.
“But his support for his home-town club Altrincham is genuine, not convenient, and he has no allegiance to either City or United.”
- Noel Gallagher reveals Guardiola text message sent to him after beating Chelsea
- Football experts under serious attack for hyping talented Man City player
That view has been echoed by Grahame Rowley, who also highlighted Taylor’s long-standing association with the non-League club.
“Anthony has always been an Altrincham fan. Even now, he gets a season ticket every year, despite the fact he can’t go to all the matches,” Rowley said.
“People around here always ask if you’re a Red or a Blue. He’s actually a great advocate for non-League football and should be praised, not criticised.”
As Manchester City and Arsenal prepare to meet in what could prove a defining encounter, the spotlight will not only be on the players and managers, but also on the officials tasked with overseeing proceedings.
