There are few figures more qualified to speak about life at Manchester City than Sergio Aguero. A player whose name is woven into the fabric of the club’s modern success, the former striker remains a keen observer of events at the Etihad Stadium.
While his own legacy was built on decisive goals and defining moments, Aguero’s attention has recently turned to a very different area of the pitch — the goalkeeping department.
In particular, he has been reflecting on the position of James Trafford, a young goalkeeper navigating the intense scrutiny and expectation that accompanies life at the top.
Trafford’s return to City last summer, in a deal worth £27 million from Burnley, was seen as a significant statement of faith in his development. Having emerged as one of England’s brightest goalkeeping prospects, he arrived back at the club determined to establish himself in the senior set-up.
Initially, opportunities came his way. He was handed responsibility during the early weeks of the campaign, trusted to anchor the side from the back. Yet elite football rarely stands still.
The subsequent arrival of Gianluigi Donnarumma from Paris Saint-Germain altered the landscape significantly, intensifying competition for the No.1 shirt and reshaping Trafford’s immediate prospects.
For a goalkeeper, perhaps more than any other position, rhythm and continuity are invaluable. Reduced minutes can test patience and resilience. However, those within the club have continued to note Trafford’s professionalism and readiness whenever called upon, particularly in domestic cup competitions.
It is in those fixtures — in the League Cup and FA Cup — that Trafford has demonstrated composure beyond his years. Performances under pressure have reinforced the belief that his long-term future remains bright, even if his present circumstances demand perseverance.
Aguero, speaking exclusively to City Xtra on behalf of Stake, offered a measured and empathetic assessment of the situation. Drawing on his own experience of competing at the highest level, the Argentine highlighted both the promise Trafford has shown and the realities of squad competition.
“That’s how competition works. [James] Trafford has shown in the games he played, especially in the League Cup and FA Cup, that he is a great goalkeeper,” said the legendary former Manchester City striker.
The praise is not faint. Aguero understands the weight of those words, particularly when directed at a young player striving to cement his place. In cup competitions, often characterised by high stakes and little margin for error, Trafford’s assured displays have caught the eye.
- Former Man City stars urge Bernardo Silva to abandon Pep Guardiola
- Pep Guardiola lists many reasons why Man City will drop points in title race
Yet Aguero was equally clear-eyed about the challenges that accompany ambition at a club of City’s stature.
“But that’s how competition works in a squad, especially as a goalkeeper,” he continued. “He has to compete with a top player like [Gianluigi] Donnarumma, and that makes it harder to start.
“It’s normal that he wants more minutes. Time will tell what is best for him.”
On one hand, Trafford is part of an elite environment designed to push players to their limits. On the other, he is at a stage of his career where consistent game-time is crucial to growth.
Goalkeeping battles are often unforgiving. Unlike outfield roles, where rotation is more frequent and tactical adjustments can create opportunities, the No.1 position typically belongs to a single individual for extended periods. Breaking through requires not only talent, but timing, resilience and occasionally circumstance.
Donnarumma’s arrival brought with it pedigree and experience at the highest level, including major European and international tournaments. Competing against such credentials inevitably raises the bar.
For Trafford, the task is not simply to perform well, but to do so in a way that leaves no doubt when chances arise.
